A transit stop is where people stand still outdoors for minutes at a time, often beside the widest, hottest roads. Every bus and tram stop in 29 city cores, set against summer surface temperature and the tree cover around it, shows where waiting for the bus means waiting in the sun.
FindingIn all 29 cities, transit stops have less tree cover around them than the city's land as a whole, parks included; in 11, from Las Vegas (94% of departures) and Phoenix (84%) to Seville, most morning departures leave from scorching, unshaded stops.
How to citeAl, Stefan. 2026. “Waiting in the Heat.” Formlume. https://research.stefanal.com/bus-stop-heat/
DataMobilityData: Mobility Database GTFS feeds; USGS Landsat 8/9; © ESA WorldCover project 2021, contains modified Copernicus Sentinel data (2021) processed by the ESA WorldCover consortium. Please also cite the original data when you use these figures.
UseFigures on white may be reused for non-commercial purposes with credit (CC BY-NC 4.0). The page design is © Stefan Al, all rights reserved; for commercial use, please get in touch.
Share of departures (bar) and of stops (dot) at stops whose surface averages 45 °C or more on clear summer mornings, with under 10% tree cover within 20 m; the number is the average surface temperature at stops. Click a city to map it.
Each dot a stop: tree cover within 20 m (across) and average summer-morning surface temperature (up).
Average tree cover within 20 m of stops against tree cover across the whole area studied, parks and water included, so stops on streets will tend to score lower. Below the line, stops are less shaded than the city around them.
Stops. Every bus, tram, trolleybus and ferry stop (subway and rail stations are left out, as their platforms are mostly underground or roofed) in the open GTFS schedules listed by the Mobility Database within 12 km of each centre, merged within 20 m; departures are scheduled 8–9 a.m. weekday departures, all lines, and weight the "by departures" figures. Cities without usable open schedules are missing.
Heat. Landsat's thermal band is measured at 100 m and resampled to 30 m, so a stop's temperature describes the street around it as much as the kerb itself. Landsat 8 and 9 surface temperature (USGS Collection 2) on up to six clear summer days, 2021–2025 (June–August, or December–February south of the equator), via Microsoft's Planetary Computer; averaged at 30 m. Clear days differ between cities, so compare broad differences; it is the temperature of roofs, roads and ground around 10:30 a.m., not air temperature.
Shade. The share of 10 m cells classed as tree cover in ESA WorldCover 2021 within 20 m of the stop. Shelters, awnings and buildings' shadows are not counted.
Tools. Python (pandas for GTFS, Rasterio and pystac for Landsat and WorldCover, NumPy) and D3.js.