Shops and cafés want passing trade, and passing trade follows the street network: some streets lie on far more of the short walks between places than others. Here every street within 5 km of the centre of 32 cities is ranked by that through-movement, and every shop and restaurant is placed on its street.
FindingThe most central tenth of streets holds about 19% of shops, nearly twice its share; 32% in Toronto and 31% in Utrecht and Copenhagen, against 11% in Beijing and 13 to 14% in Tokyo, Madrid and New York.
How to citeAl, Stefan. 2026. “Where the Shops Are.” Formlume. https://research.stefanal.com/main-streets/
Data© OpenStreetMap contributors; Overture Maps Foundation. Please also cite the original data when you use these figures.
UseFigures on white may be reused for non-commercial purposes with credit (CC BY-NC 4.0). The page design is © Stefan Al, all rights reserved; for commercial use, please get in touch.
ThemeStreets and mobility
Streets are sorted by centrality and cut into ten groups of equal length, from the most central tenth to the least. If shops ignored the network, each tenth would hold 10% of them.
Each disc is 10 km across. Below each, the shares of shops in each centrality tenth. Click a city to explore it.
Walking network from OpenStreetMap (ODbL) via OSMnx. Shops, cafés, restaurants and services from the Overture Maps Foundation places theme (confidence 0.5 or higher), each assigned to the nearest street within 25 m.
Centrality. For 3,000 random starting points, the shortest walking route to every street within 2 km is traced, and each street is credited with the routes that pass along it. This is a sampled, 2 km version of what space syntax calls choice and network analysts call betweenness, the measure behind tools such as sDNA and the DeCodingSpaces toolbox.
Caveats. Shortest routes are not actual flows: people take transit, prefer pleasant streets and drive. Overture's coverage of small shops is strong in Europe and North America and thinner in parts of Asia and Latin America. A shop is assigned to one street even on a corner.
The question is old: Bill Hillier's natural movement theory (1993) argued that configuration drives movement and movement attracts shops. This page tests the whole chain, from configuration to shops, for dozens of cities at once, without observing movement itself. The walking network includes footways and separately mapped sidewalks, which can double street length where sidewalks are drawn; and the place data are thin in some cities, Beijing especially.