In the late 1930s the federal Home Owners' Loan Corporation graded the neighbourhoods of some two hundred American cities for mortgage risk, from A, "best", to D, "hazardous", outlined in red. The grades tracked race as much as housing. Eighty-five years later, satellites measure how hot those same neighbourhoods get on summer days.
FindingIn 164 of 185 cities the neighbourhoods graded D in the 1930s are hotter in summer today than those graded A, and across all 185 the D areas average 2.9 °C hotter, with half the tree cover.
How to citeAl, Stefan. 2026. “Redlined and Hotter.” Formlume. https://research.stefanal.com/redlining-heat/
DataMapping Inequality (University of Richmond); USGS Landsat 8/9; © ESA WorldCover project 2021, contains modified Copernicus Sentinel data (2021) processed by the ESA WorldCover consortium; US Census Bureau ACS. Please also cite the original data when you use these figures.
UseFigures on white may be reused for non-commercial purposes with credit (CC BY-NC 4.0). The page design is © Stefan Al, all rights reserved; for commercial use, please get in touch.
Summer surface temperature of each grade relative to the average of all graded areas in its city. Cities sorted by the gap between D and A areas.
Grades. Robert K. Nelson, LaDale Winling et al., Mapping Inequality, Digital Scholarship Lab, University of Richmond (CC BY-NC), via the Mapping Inequality–census crosswalk. Only HOLC City Survey maps with at least eight graded areas are included.
Heat. Landsat 8 and 9 Collection 2 surface temperature (USGS), June–August 2021–2025, up to eight clear scenes per city, read from Microsoft's Planetary Computer. Each scene is expressed relative to its own mean over the city's graded areas, then averaged, as in Hoffman, Shandas & Pendleton (2020), Climate 8(1):12. Surface temperature is the temperature of roofs and pavement at about 10–11 a.m., not air temperature.
Trees and residents. Tree and built-up cover from ESA WorldCover 2021 (10 m). Residents from the Census Bureau's American Community Survey 2019–2023, allocated from 2020 tracts by area, so figures are approximate for small areas.
Reading it. The maps record how lenders and local agents judged neighbourhoods; they did not create every difference, and many disparities were already in place. What the data show is how closely the old lines still match the hot, treeless parts of each city.